
There should be a specific term for artists who create, or at least align themselves with, pop songs that feel like massive events, not once or twice in their career, but over and over again. Madonna did it, of course. Michael Jackson did it. Cher, Janet, Beyoncé, George Michael, Britney, even relative newcomer Rihanna – they could all point to occasions where they’ve been part of Pop Events time and time again. And then we come to Lady Gaga, who has managed to squish, by my count and in my opinion, six massive 100% amazing fuck-off 10/10 pop songs into two and a half albums. ‘Poker Face’ and ‘Paparazzi’ from her debut The Fame, ‘Bad Romance’, ‘Telephone’ and ‘Dance In The Dark’ from the follow-up EP The Fame Monster, and ‘Judas’, which I have already gushed over, from Born This Way.
Born This Way is one of the strangest records to ever be released by an artist at the top of their game. Compare Michael Jackson and Madonna when they were in Gaga’s post-Fame Monster position: Madonna’s breakthrough Like A Virgin was followed by the perfect but safe True Blue, while Michael’s Thriller was trailed by Bad, which attempted to repeat the formula and almost accidentally came up with some songs that actually surpassed some of the tracks on the predecessor. But Lady Gaga comes out with a harsh, divisive, visually confused, thematically ridiculous album filled almost equally with potential singles and experiments. If nothing else, Born This Way is risky.
Let us begin with the album cover. Definitely my favourite of the year so far, the place it has in the campaign really sums up this whole shebang. On a record called Born This Way, with a first single about loving yourself for who you are and never changing, our hero decides to stick her head on a motorbike and become as removed as possible from the natural state she’s been urging her fans to love. It’s funny and certainly grabs your attention, but it also shows that in contrast with the on-point image decisions for The Fame and Monster, this album doesn’t have a clear direction. In a way, that makes the juxtaposition of title and cover the best possible representation of the music within.
This album is mostly front-loaded with the best tracks, if not the most commercial ones – some of the experiments like ‘Government Hooker’ and ‘Schieße’ wouldn’t be hit singles but they’re exciting and fun to listen to, and I can see them becoming among the songs I come back to most. There is nothing to say about lead single ‘Born This Way’ that hasn’t been said before, other than I still really, really like it. ‘Judas’ is even better and still feels like a masterpiece to these ears, and thankfully it sets the noisy-but-melodic tone for many of the other songs. ‘Hair’ and ‘Marry The Night’ aren’t quite as thrilling as the songs that surround them in the first half, ‘Americano’ is ludicrous but fun, and the slow-motion half-ballad ‘Bloody Mary’ is a bit of a throwback to some of the best moments on The Fame, which, by the way, sounds light years away now, like the work of a different artist altogether.
Those eight songs are the basis for an album that could’ve been perfect. But, on the deluxe edition, which let’s face it, everyone who cares is buying, we’ve still got nine songs to go. ‘Black Jesus † Amen Fashion’ (I know, I know) is a less successful version of the werq-werq-runway-fashion-werq style of tracks like ‘Scheiße’, while ‘Bad Kids’ and ‘Fashion Of His Love’ sort of just float past me, never grabbing my attention in any meaningful way, though they sound fine while they’re playing. ‘Highway Unicorn (Road To Love)’ (again, I know) is a precursor the orgasmic album closer, blending the power-pop of her idol Bruce Springsteen with stuttering dance beats and a Cher-when-she-sort-of-went-hair-metal-that-time vocal.
‘Heavy Metal Lover’ is a more of a mood piece than an album highlight, and ‘Electric Chapel’ is similar in that they both have vocals that are a bit more subtle than usual. All this, including ‘The Queen’, which acts like a bridge between ‘Highway Unicorn’ and what’s to come, feels like a warm up for the finalé, two huge songs that sound even bigger when played back-to-back.
‘Yoü And I’, complete with an umlaut for no reason other than to remind us that even when she’s singing a conventional power ballad like this, Lady Gaga is still wacky and ker-azzayy, is the spiritual cousin of earlier songs ‘Brown Eyes’ and ‘Speechless’. It doesn’t reach the emotional height of ‘Speechless’ but it does a great job of erasing any weakness that may have been made apparent by the preceding few songs. Imagine if the first eight songs had been immediately followed by the final two, to make a ten track album, and the remaining tracks had been above-average B-sides. That would have been too good to be true.
And so, we come to ‘The Edge Of Glory’. My third favourite on the album after the title track and ‘Judas’, it mixes so many amazing things about so many amazing genres: odd Enya-style intro, odd Aqua-style vocals at the start, Eurodance beat, and the ‘Living On A Prayer’/'Song For The Lonely’ hybrid of a chorus that is only beaten by the amazing, amazing saxophone solo. When the saxophone meets the reintroduction of the beat at about 3:30 – fucking hell, that is what music is all about for me. I live for moments like that.
I like that Gaga takes herself really seriously. Pop music is serious business, and I need to believe that because if it isn’t then my life has been a collossal waste of time. But it works against her sometimes, and it feels as though some sections of pop fandom have decided that it is “her time”, and that the backlash is due. I’m glad I don’t devote my time talking endlessly about artists I hate – imagine how fucking boring it would be for me to have to focus on Jessie J all the time – but if that’s what gets some corners of the internet going then good for them. I suppose the point is that Gaga has made an album strong enough to carry her past the hatred, at least through to the next album campaign – what position she’ll be in then remains to be seen.
I don’t think Gaga is an icon on the level of MJ or Madonna. Not even close. I don’t think she’s the saviour of pop music, or the messiah. She’s not my mother and I’m not a little monster. But she makes amazing music and amazing music is what I’m interested in. Born This Way is not perfect, it’s too long and The Fame Monster EP remains her greatest achievement, but my god when this album gets it right it gets it so, incredibly right. Take away the ridiculous clothes, the psycho fans, the psycho haters, the overly serious reviews like this one, the chart positions – does the music stack up? The answer is yes for me and that’s all that really matters.
8/10
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.